Hogan Lovells 2024 Election Impact and Congressional Outlook Report
When Mr. Joseph Biden takes office on 20 January 2021, he will be a seasoned foreign policy hand facing a new, challenging landscape in U.S.-China relations. His policymaking process will be a return to the familiar – working with allies, renewing U.S. leadership in multilateral institutions, and dogged classical diplomacy at all levels – but he faces a changed bilateral relationship that will make abrupt shifts to existing policies hard to pursue or enact. He will also face bipartisan domestic pressure to take stronger actions against China. As a result, the U.S.-China relationship is likely to remain contentious. However, the return to traditional policy-making means financial institutions and other companies will have more ways to influence policy and navigate what will continue to be a challenging regulatory environment.
During his presidential campaign, Mr. Biden largely avoided direct skirmishes with the Trump Administration on China policy, knowing that the muscular approach under President Trump towards China is popular in political battleground states and on both sides of the aisle on Capitol Hill. Instead, he criticized President Trump for not being strong enough on China and for his scattershot approach to tariffs. Still, he declined to specify how his potential future Administration would approach the relationship differently, apart from working more closely with U.S. allies. Mr. Biden benefited from this approach politically, as it kept the focus on the domestic issues of the pandemic response and lagging economy, two areas that were winners for his campaign. But this tactic leaves the business community wondering how, precisely, Mr. Biden will approach the U.S.-China relationship and how they should respond.
An incoming Biden Administration will be under pressure to maintain a foreign policy that confronts China on national security and trade matters. As such, it is unlikely that a Biden Administration will make significant shifts in current U.S. policies towards China, at least in the first few months of 2021. Any effort to roll back the Section 301 tariffs on Chinese goods, for example, would require a quid pro quo from China, which would then likely involve at least some effort to deal with difficult systemic issues that were mostly put aside in President Trump’s “Phase One” deal. Similarly, some Biden (campaign? Future Administration?) foreign policy advisors have called for an effort to work with China on climate change, but it is not clear how much can be achieved in terms of substantive changes in Chinese domestic policies. Much like President Trump, who found himself flanked on either side by China hawks and doves, urging him to go further or cautioning him against going too far, Mr. Biden may also find himself stuck between wanting to have a more collaborative relationship with China and needing to take decisive action to address unfair trade practices and national security concerns.
Therefore, we largely expect many of the Trump Administration’s policies on China to continue, barring any unforeseen changes to the systemic dynamics between the two countries. Based on a review of Mr. Biden’s public statements, here are a few policy specifics that financial institutions can expect:
Even if the politics and policy towards China do not change much, a Biden Administration committed to traditional avenues of governance and diplomacy should lead to a more predictable policy-making process and more ways for companies to shape his Administration’s China policy. Companies should start working on their trade policy wish lists now, as this process is already underway.
Authored by Ben Kostrzewa and Andrew McGinty.